Aesthetic debates sound film, voice, director, cinema. The deserter 100 years of soviet cinema senses of cinema. Eisenstein, pudovkin, and alexandrov argue for sound to. Germany is working intensively in the same direction. Alexandrov and dziga vertov the dream of a sound film has come true. Eisenstein on eisenstein, the director of potemkin 1926 6.
Eisenstein, pudovkin, and alexandrov a statement on sound. Soviet fidelity and the pet shop boys springerlink. These major soviet filmmakers saw potential dangers in the new technique, but did not therefore reject it. The statement rehashed earlier soviet arguments about cinema as an art form separate from theatre and went on to propose that sound montage be. Only a contrapuntal use of sound in relation to the visual montage piece will afford a new potentiality of montage development and perfection. Sergei eisenstein university of california, irvine. Upon returning from hollywood and mexico in the late 1930s, he left behind the densely edited style of celebrated silents like battleship potemkin and october, turning instead to historical sources, contradictory audiovisuals, and theatrical sets for his grandiose yet subversive. First published in english in the new york herald tribune, 21 september 1928. The dramaturgy of film form the dialetical approach to film form 1929 11. With its dream of asynchronous, antirealistic sound, it was an idealistic text, and its ideas would never be fully followed through. Eisenstein a dialectic approach to film form the filmic. Consequently, it was not surprising that the first expression of this impulse came from eisenstein, pudovkin, and grigori alexandrov.
Appendix a a statement on the soundfilm by eisenstein, pudovkin, and alexandrov. W ith the invention of a practical sound film, the americans have placed it on the first st ep of substantial an d rapid realization. Sergei eisenstein the theory of montage film editing. Eisenstein, sergei, vsevolod pudovkin, and grigori alexandrov. Discuss eisensteins theory of intellectual montage using one or more contemporary film or media works that exhibit or manifest this theory.
Eisenstein achieved so much in the field of editing that it would be most useful to present his theory first and then look at how he put theory into practice. Louis baudry ideological effects of the basic cinematographic apparatus christian metz aural objects sergei eisenstein, vsevelod pudovkin, and grigori alexandrov statement on sound mary ann doane the voice. Alexandrov 19031984, who issued a joint statement on sound in august 1928. Responsibility edited by leo braudy, marshall cohen.
Sound in film should create an orchestral counterpoint of visual and aural images. Vsevolod pudovkin was born in penza into a russian family, the third of six children. What does independent mean in the context of broadcast or cable television production andor reception. Academic journal article music, sound and the moving image a statement on sound studies with apologies to sergei eisenstein, vsevolod pudovkin, and grigori alexandrov.
Alexandrov, a statement on sound 1928, in film sound. In their 1928 manifesto sound and image, the soviet directors sergey eisenstein, vsevolod pudovkin, and grigory aleksandrov denounced synchronous sound in favour of asynchronous, contrapuntal. Both pudovkin and eisenstein were pioneers in the new techniques of montage, evolving the craft along with other filmmaking elements. According to eisenstein, pudovkin and alexandrov, montage in the 1920s soviet sense of juxtaposition is the indisputable axiom upon. Sergei eisenstein, vsevolod pudovkin, and grigori alexandrov, statement on sound, in the film. The late 1920s gave birth to oswald the lucky rabbit september 1927, mickey mouse may 1928 and the statement on sound august 1928, written collectively by eisenstein, pudovkin and alexandrov. Ideology and the practice of sound editing and mixing, by mary ann doane technology and aesthetics of film sound, by john belton part ii. Music, sound, and the moving image list of issues volume 2, issue 2 music, sound, and the moving image. Eisenstein a dialectic approach to film form the filmic fourth dimension the from cmst 10100 at university of chicago. Vsevolod pudovkin article about vsevolod pudovkin by the. Upon returning from hollywood and mexico in the late 1930s, he left behind the densely edited style of celebrated silents like battleship potemkin and october, turning instead to historical sources, contradictory audiovisuals, and theatrical sets for his. Much debate has focused on exploring ways in which sound might be associated with the image. I sergei eisenstein, vsvolod pudovkin, and gregori alexandrov, a statement, trans. It reflects what sergei eisenstein, pudovkin and alexandrov wrote in a statement 1928.
It was an attempt to view the new technology of sound as a gain for the evolution of film as an art. Alexandrov asynchronism as a principle of sound film, by v. Casting a long shadow over discussions of audiovisual synchronization is the 1928 joint statement on sound published by eisenstein, pudovkin and alexandrov, in which the three soviet directors argued that cinematic soundimage relations should be governed by the principles of montage rather than by forms of naturalism. Eisensteins hopes and fears for the sound cinema were necessarily. We will also look in detail at the classic statement on sound by eisenstein, pudovkin and alexandrov. Sergei eisenstein, long regarded as a pioneer of film art, changed cinematic strategies halfway through his career. What binds all these classical theorists together is nei ther their acceptance of sound nor their. Eisenstein intended to use his filmmaking to shake his audience and evoke a response, forcing them to get up, take action, and challenge political ideologies. Eisenstein s german manuscript lent by the museum of modem art film library of a dialectic approach to film form, and the frames chosen by eisenstein for its illus. Russian and soviet cinema in documents, 18961939, ed. Vsevolod pudovkin, and gregori alexandrov, a statement, in eisenstein, film form, trans. A statement on the soundfilm by eisenstein, pudovkin, and alexandrov 257 appendix b. The sound of film online bookings and course catalogue. Sergei eisenstein wrote repeatedly about sound and music in cinema, from his contribution to the collective statement on sound, coauthored with vsevolod pudovkin and grigori alexandrov in 1928, through his discussion of audiovisual cinema and vertical montage in the montage essays of 1938 to 1940, to his late1940s articles on sergei prokofiev, and color and sound each of these built on the earlier work and confirmed his original commitment to sound as an active element in.
May 1928 and the statement on sound august 1928, written collectively by eisenstein, pudovkin and alexandrov. Jay leyda twelve essays written between 1928 and 1945 that demonstrate key points in the development of eisensteins film theory and in particular his analysis of the soundfilm medium. Sound, speech, music in soviet and postsoviet cinema on jstor. Sound sergei eisenstein, vsevelod pudovkin, and grigori alexandrov statement on sound christian metz aural objects mary ann doane the voice in the cinema. Their statement was published in a leningrad magazine in 1928. Discussion of eisensteins theory and practice in the use of sound from his first. The first experiments with sound must be directed toward its noncoincidence with visual images. The cinematographic principle and the ideogral\1 it is a weird and wonderful feat to have written a. Subscribe to senses of cinema to receive news of our latest cinema journal. A statement on sound ussr, 1928 sergei eisenstein, vsevolod pudovkin, and grigori alexandrov first published in russian in zhizn iskusstva 32 1928.
Eisenstein, pudovkin, and alexandrov, statement on sound eisenstein, pudovkin and alexandrov wish for ideas contained in a film 372 to be sped throughout the whole globe rather than to be imprisoned within national markets 372. Notes from a directors laboratory 261 notes on texts lind trtmslations 266 sources 268 index 273. The importance of sound invention in film raindance. A statement on the soundfilm by eisenstein, pudovkin, and alexandrov. Grigori vasilyevich aleksandrov or alexandrov russian.
252 1160 1213 1258 1 338 1272 636 548 727 631 239 1297 193 316 438 1451 657 141 1433 463 566 20 1008 1579 1428 847 1519 982 1452 300 1383 871 598 1174 434 330 1002 413